may i suggest....

a spider?

the frog dice face from a card game I play called Ashes. There's more little animals here on the sidebar, I like these icons a lot.

the treachery of images

plants are good

or a flaming skull

permanent corpse paint

I won three hours of tattooing in a Pride fundraiser a couple of years ago and I used it to start a sleeve.

the gift certificate itself

and for perhaps a serious answer: your favourite punctuation mark? mine is the ampersand!

Mouse

What did you end up getting btw